Welcome, Guest

1. •  
     CommentAuthorJon Wan (CommentTimeFeb 26th 2008)

    
   For transparency purposes, may i suggest that a thumbs-up (or thanks) be issued once only either weekly or monthly to each user?
   
   ie - 1 person may only do it once a month/week to a each different forumer?
   
   - it promotes fairness of the issuance of these thumb-ups (because now you will only get 1 from each user most, either on monthly or weekly basis)
   
   - it generates more movements for forumers to contribute more constructively as by then these thumb-ups would have to be earned
   
   - current system allows the creation of "clone" accounts to manifest
   (i am not pointing fingers at current users, this is just my experience from other forum systems)
   
   JWNY
2. •  
     CommentAuthorcrunchychoconut (CommentTimeFeb 26th 2008)

    
   actually i don't think it's necessary. cos i believe thumbs-ups should be issued to every deserving post, and it is possible (even common) for forumers to produce more than 1 deserving post per week...
3. •  
     CommentAuthormacadamia^n (CommentTimeFeb 26th 2008)

    
   each user can give 1 other forummer 1 per day?or no more than 2?
4. •  
     CommentAuthorSCdreamer (CommentTimeFeb 26th 2008)

    
   i think its not necessary...as it should be based on merit and value to the thumbs up giver...hmmm...how about monitoring for 1 more month before you decide on a thumb up limitation.
   
   the key function of the thumbs up is for the moderators to provide incentives , I would suggest keep the currrent system for quantitive indications, and then moderators do a qualitative checks on the post to decide if this member deserves the incentive.
   
   I would say don't over regulate...or we could just get rid of the whole thing...if its good posting, a personal THANK YOU post is better.

   Chicken Rice Man
5. •  
     CommentAuthorpicky gourmet (CommentTimeFeb 26th 2008)

    
   JW you think give points ah? =P
   
   Don't matter ...who bothers to cheat with this stuff anyway....plus it gets pretty obvious....
   
   Anyway HGW is a above board food site for foodies not a popularity contest or a discreet site where thumbs up means a lot =P

   Chicken Rice Man, SCdreamer, crunchychoconut
6. •  
     CommentAuthorPANERAI (CommentTimeFeb 28th 2008 edited)

    
   Bro JW....this ain't no Sam's cafe hor...ha ha : )
7. •  
     CommentAuthorJon Wan (CommentTimeFeb 28th 2008)

    
   forget it ... close thread... sniff
8. •  
     CommentAuthorLinda (CommentTimeFeb 28th 2008)

    
   I thought it was a good idea JW. =)
   
   Although I'm not here enough for any of that to matter.
9. •  
     CommentAuthorPANERAI (CommentTimeFeb 29th 2008)

    
   JW...ha ha : )